NCAA Football 2005 vs. Madden 2005

[Magnum Force]

Im not big on football but.....which do you think is better?

I prefer NCAA (just do...no reason).

Tell me which you think is better....compare and contrast! (i sound like an english teacher lol)

Does any1 have NCAA and have it gotten scratched or frozen on you alot??? Me and like 10 of my friends have the same problem.... :?

[TallFolk]

im a big madden nfl fan, but im very good at running the option on ncaa.

[~Saint~]

i prefer Ncaa as well the gameplay is more realistic... cuz in Madden they never drop balls rarely ... now the ppl in nFl r good but not invisible in Ncaa they drop mroe so u dont sweat it wen u blow coverage sometimes

[Angus]

I like madden a lot. But I like college better. Way more realistic.

[Magnum Force]

hey guys, can anyone answer that question at the bottom of my topic post????

cuz its making me mad (not this, the problem)


if you cant answer, that's ok. its prolly just their playstations or something....

[Angus]

Mine hasnt gotten scrtached. But my freinds has gotten scrtached and it froze a lot.

[Tiger]

Originally Posted by ~Saint~

i prefer Ncaa as well the gameplay is more realistic... cuz in Madden they never drop balls rarely

how often do you see a professional player drop a ball? maybe 7 or 8 times a year

They might not always catch it, but thats because of coverage - not the recievers hands. Ever play on all madden?? The coverage is insane, and you have to throw it perfect... like the NFL.

[babelfish987]

I play NCAA Football 2005 as much as Socom II. It's a great game, but there's a lot of problems with the server sometimes as far as connecting with other people. Glitching is a problem but there is that in everygame. But back to my point i think NCAA is 10x's better than Madden.

[MASTA JJ]

ncaa same reason most of u guys like it. i played high school football and it reminds me more of high school play..

[scubasteve213]

i think NCAA 2005 is better than madden 2005